How do you "fix" college football?

1SEIACLONE

Well-Known Member
Jun 2, 2024
5,693
5,665
113
64
Ames Iowa
After the Campbell deal and watching the football playoff show today, the thought occurred to me, "how do we fix this mess?" So here is what I am thinking.

1. Hire a commissioner that is in overall charge of the sport, this person would have the final say in any problem, over the conference commissioners, the networks and everything related to college football

2. Set the calendar. Coaches can only be hired from January 1st till February 1st, I know that might harm teams in the playoff, but if you are playing in the playoff you are most likely not going to be leaving for another school. Transfer portal runs from February 1st to March 1st. Before spring practice and after the coaching window. Signing day for all high school players starts March 1st till, March 15th. The HS player knows who the coach will be and which players the team has brought in out of the portal.

3. All players have to sign a 2 year contract with the school, leave after a year, you lose a year of eligibility, all players have 5 years to play 5 seasons. That is all you get, you get hurt and lose a year, sorry, 5 is all you get.

4. NIL, football teams are allowed 20 million total for pay for play, that is your entire budget, you want to spend $6 million on the Manning kid, have at it, but you only have $14 million for the rest of the roster. Money is paid out one year at a time, over the life of the 5 years, you leave early to the NFL, you miss out on the remaining funds.

5. All teams will play a 12 games schedule only against P4 schools and a list of the best 20 G5 schools. Every team will play 6 home and 6 away games, and. nine conference games, The other three games will be determined by how you finish in your league. Much like the NFL, if you are Georgia and win the SEC, then next year your schedule is Duke, Indiana and TT. Alabama you get Ohio State, Virginia and BYU and right down the list.

6. All media contracts are equal for all teams in the leagues, worked out by the overall commissioner, so ESPN is not paired up with the SEC or Fox with the B10, you are working with college football inc.

7. 16 team playoff, B10 and SEC get 4 spots, ACC and B12 get 2 each, that is 12 spots, leaving 4 other spots for ND, G5 schools and the rest. All teams that win their league get in, and the top 8 teams host the first round games.

Everything is based on the NFL model and is designed to make all the games as combative as possible with fewer haves and have nots. Now I do not expect any of this to actually happen, but something must be done to fix the sport. Agree, disagree, but please leave some feedback.
 
You'd also have to allow non students to participate in spring drills. You can move the portal to February but you can't move when the semester begins.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Letterkenny
After the Campbell deal and watching the football playoff show today, the thought occurred to me, "how do we fix this mess?" So here is what I am thinking.

1. Hire a commissioner that is in overall charge of the sport, this person would have the final say in any problem, over the conference commissioners, the networks and everything related to college football

2. Set the calendar. Coaches can only be hired from January 1st till February 1st, I know that might harm teams in the playoff, but if you are playing in the playoff you are most likely not going to be leaving for another school. Transfer portal runs from February 1st to March 1st. Before spring practice and after the coaching window. Signing day for all high school players starts March 1st till, March 15th. The HS player knows who the coach will be and which players the team has brought in out of the portal.

3. All players have to sign a 2 year contract with the school, leave after a year, you lose a year of eligibility, all players have 5 years to play 5 seasons. That is all you get, you get hurt and lose a year, sorry, 5 is all you get.

4. NIL, football teams are allowed 20 million total for pay for play, that is your entire budget, you want to spend $6 million on the Manning kid, have at it, but you only have $14 million for the rest of the roster. Money is paid out one year at a time, over the life of the 5 years, you leave early to the NFL, you miss out on the remaining funds.

5. All teams will play a 12 games schedule only against P4 schools and a list of the best 20 G5 schools. Every team will play 6 home and 6 away games, and. nine conference games, The other three games will be determined by how you finish in your league. Much like the NFL, if you are Georgia and win the SEC, then next year your schedule is Duke, Indiana and TT. Alabama you get Ohio State, Virginia and BYU and right down the list.

6. All media contracts are equal for all teams in the leagues, worked out by the overall commissioner, so ESPN is not paired up with the SEC or Fox with the B10, you are working with college football inc.

7. 16 team playoff, B10 and SEC get 4 spots, ACC and B12 get 2 each, that is 12 spots, leaving 4 other spots for ND, G5 schools and the rest. All teams that win their league get in, and the top 8 teams host the first round games.

Everything is based on the NFL model and is designed to make all the games as combative as possible with fewer haves and have nots. Now I do not expect any of this to actually happen, but something must be done to fix the sport. Agree, disagree, but please leave some feedback.

Makes way too much sense, so obviously it’s ludicrous
 
  • Like
Reactions: Letterkenny
After the Campbell deal and watching the football playoff show today, the thought occurred to me, "how do we fix this mess?" So here is what I am thinking.

1. Hire a commissioner that is in overall charge of the sport, this person would have the final say in any problem, over the conference commissioners, the networks and everything related to college football

2. Set the calendar. Coaches can only be hired from January 1st till February 1st, I know that might harm teams in the playoff, but if you are playing in the playoff you are most likely not going to be leaving for another school. Transfer portal runs from February 1st to March 1st. Before spring practice and after the coaching window. Signing day for all high school players starts March 1st till, March 15th. The HS player knows who the coach will be and which players the team has brought in out of the portal.

3. All players have to sign a 2 year contract with the school, leave after a year, you lose a year of eligibility, all players have 5 years to play 5 seasons. That is all you get, you get hurt and lose a year, sorry, 5 is all you get.

4. NIL, football teams are allowed 20 million total for pay for play, that is your entire budget, you want to spend $6 million on the Manning kid, have at it, but you only have $14 million for the rest of the roster. Money is paid out one year at a time, over the life of the 5 years, you leave early to the NFL, you miss out on the remaining funds.

5. All teams will play a 12 games schedule only against P4 schools and a list of the best 20 G5 schools. Every team will play 6 home and 6 away games, and. nine conference games, The other three games will be determined by how you finish in your league. Much like the NFL, if you are Georgia and win the SEC, then next year your schedule is Duke, Indiana and TT. Alabama you get Ohio State, Virginia and BYU and right down the list.

6. All media contracts are equal for all teams in the leagues, worked out by the overall commissioner, so ESPN is not paired up with the SEC or Fox with the B10, you are working with college football inc.

7. 16 team playoff, B10 and SEC get 4 spots, ACC and B12 get 2 each, that is 12 spots, leaving 4 other spots for ND, G5 schools and the rest. All teams that win their league get in, and the top 8 teams host the first round games.

Everything is based on the NFL model and is designed to make all the games as combative as possible with fewer haves and have nots. Now I do not expect any of this to actually happen, but something must be done to fix the sport. Agree, disagree, but please leave some feedback.

I like except #4. Need to completely get rid of pay for play.
 
Get rid of the playoff selection committee. The championship tournament consists of the individual conference champions. Bowl games for the non qualifiers. Finish 2nd in your conference, try harder next year.
 
Agree on a lot of this.

1). There needs to be some kind of salary cap like there is in pro sports. You could argue if dynasties are good or bad for any sport, but I think it's a given the pro leagues all understand that a complete lack of parity is not a good thing. Look at how they all handle the draft (worst to first), how the NFL balances schedules, etc. It's not good for the game when the same 4 teams are good and the same 8 teams are atrocious every year.

2). There needs to be some concept of a contract. College sports right now is basically a pro league where there is free agency for every player every year. It would be absolute chaos.

3). Similarly, there should be a limit on the number of times that you can transfer. Was watching CBB (I realize this is a football thread, but point remains) the other night and they were talking about a player who attended 3 high schools and now was on his fourth college. This is insane. If they can't legally get away with an outright prohibition, they need to derive some kind of disincentive at minimum.

4). Some objective criteria for the playoff. As much as we all love March Madness there is obviously still some subjectivity there. That said, I think they've come a long way with the metrics based approach. With 64 (actually 68 teams) the "cut line" is at the point where those teams have no real chance of winning 6 in a row so realize this is not apples to apples. But the committee is doing basically whatever the f**k they want and ESPN is a mouthpiece for it. Herbstreit - who I normally don't mind - was on TV ealier twisting himself into pretzels defending the committee for flipping ND and Miami today. I think it was the right decision, but there is no accountability for how this suddenly switched today after over a month of doing it differently. Same with the double standard about not being punished for losing CCGs. And the double standard between the FSU QB injury and the Ole Miss coaching staff situation.
 
Do you mean in a way that can legally work? If yes, I think #2, #3, and #4 would lose on an anti trust suit.

I like the ideas, but to do most of this we have to have a Players Union and a Coaches Union. I think it’s time for the players to be employees even though I think that would be devastating to ISU.
 
Do you mean in a way that can legally work? If yes, I think #2, #3, and #4 would lose on an anti trust suit.

I like the ideas, but to do most of this we have to have a Players Union and a Coaches Union. I think it’s time for the players to be employees even though I think that would be devastating to ISU.

Congress should have carved CFB out of antitrust decades ago.
 
After the Campbell deal and watching the football playoff show today, the thought occurred to me, "how do we fix this mess?" So here is what I am thinking.

1. Hire a commissioner that is in overall charge of the sport, this person would have the final say in any problem, over the conference commissioners, the networks and everything related to college football

2. Set the calendar. Coaches can only be hired from January 1st till February 1st, I know that might harm teams in the playoff, but if you are playing in the playoff you are most likely not going to be leaving for another school. Transfer portal runs from February 1st to March 1st. Before spring practice and after the coaching window. Signing day for all high school players starts March 1st till, March 15th. The HS player knows who the coach will be and which players the team has brought in out of the portal.

3. All players have to sign a 2 year contract with the school, leave after a year, you lose a year of eligibility, all players have 5 years to play 5 seasons. That is all you get, you get hurt and lose a year, sorry, 5 is all you get.

4. NIL, football teams are allowed 20 million total for pay for play, that is your entire budget, you want to spend $6 million on the Manning kid, have at it, but you only have $14 million for the rest of the roster. Money is paid out one year at a time, over the life of the 5 years, you leave early to the NFL, you miss out on the remaining funds.

5. All teams will play a 12 games schedule only against P4 schools and a list of the best 20 G5 schools. Every team will play 6 home and 6 away games, and. nine conference games, The other three games will be determined by how you finish in your league. Much like the NFL, if you are Georgia and win the SEC, then next year your schedule is Duke, Indiana and TT. Alabama you get Ohio State, Virginia and BYU and right down the list.

6. All media contracts are equal for all teams in the leagues, worked out by the overall commissioner, so ESPN is not paired up with the SEC or Fox with the B10, you are working with college football inc.

7. 16 team playoff, B10 and SEC get 4 spots, ACC and B12 get 2 each, that is 12 spots, leaving 4 other spots for ND, G5 schools and the rest. All teams that win their league get in, and the top 8 teams host the first round games.

Everything is based on the NFL model and is designed to make all the games as combative as possible with fewer haves and have nots. Now I do not expect any of this to actually happen, but something must be done to fix the sport. Agree, disagree, but please leave some feedback.
I like the money/contract aspect of it, but the Ohio States and Alabama's will figure out a way to cheat to their advantage.

Move the season up a week. 80 teams. Add more teams to get to 80. Like Boise, Tulane, etc...

Split conferences up into smaller conferences with divisions. Play division opponents twice every year. Play rest of games against non division teams in your conference. Division winners are in. Then have so many wild cards from each conference based on record. 24 team playoff. If they want to keep the stupid conf title games then have division winners play each other and the title game winners get a 1st round bye in the playoff.

Won't happen of course because of the greedy slimeballs in the SEC and Big 10.
 
Seems having the players making money is ruining the sport.

Well, openly making money anyway.

'NIL' happening at the same time as loosening the transfer rules has made for a perfect storm of problems.

I'd have preferred to leave it at loosening transfer rules if I were to pick one.
 
Kind of. But it’s unethical to have coaches/ADs/media/vendors/etc with multimillion dollar contracts, while the individuals putting in the labor (and putting their life/health on the line) get diddly squat.

They should've gotten a monthly stipend on top of their six figure free college ride, and everything else they got that was paid for. But that's impossible now. Div 1 college football is a cess pool. It's just dumb now.

Seriously considering going to D3 or NAIA games on Saturdays if I need a college football fix.
 
After the Campbell deal and watching the football playoff show today, the thought occurred to me, "how do we fix this mess?" So here is what I am thinking.

1. Hire a commissioner that is in overall charge of the sport, this person would have the final say in any problem, over the conference commissioners, the networks and everything related to college football

2. Set the calendar. Coaches can only be hired from January 1st till February 1st, I know that might harm teams in the playoff, but if you are playing in the playoff you are most likely not going to be leaving for another school. Transfer portal runs from February 1st to March 1st. Before spring practice and after the coaching window. Signing day for all high school players starts March 1st till, March 15th. The HS player knows who the coach will be and which players the team has brought in out of the portal.

3. All players have to sign a 2 year contract with the school, leave after a year, you lose a year of eligibility, all players have 5 years to play 5 seasons. That is all you get, you get hurt and lose a year, sorry, 5 is all you get.

4. NIL, football teams are allowed 20 million total for pay for play, that is your entire budget, you want to spend $6 million on the Manning kid, have at it, but you only have $14 million for the rest of the roster. Money is paid out one year at a time, over the life of the 5 years, you leave early to the NFL, you miss out on the remaining funds.

5. All teams will play a 12 games schedule only against P4 schools and a list of the best 20 G5 schools. Every team will play 6 home and 6 away games, and. nine conference games, The other three games will be determined by how you finish in your league. Much like the NFL, if you are Georgia and win the SEC, then next year your schedule is Duke, Indiana and TT. Alabama you get Ohio State, Virginia and BYU and right down the list.

6. All media contracts are equal for all teams in the leagues, worked out by the overall commissioner, so ESPN is not paired up with the SEC or Fox with the B10, you are working with college football inc.

7. 16 team playoff, B10 and SEC get 4 spots, ACC and B12 get 2 each, that is 12 spots, leaving 4 other spots for ND, G5 schools and the rest. All teams that win their league get in, and the top 8 teams host the first round games.

Everything is based on the NFL model and is designed to make all the games as combative as possible with fewer haves and have nots. Now I do not expect any of this to actually happen, but something must be done to fix the sport. Agree, disagree, but please leave some feedback.
Items 1 and 2 makes sense.
Items 3, 4, 5, 6 would need more negotiating with the players. I not sure as a player, I'd want a cap on payments unless it was represented as a % of the total revenue if revenue continues to grow from new markets.
Item 7 Although I don't like the idea of the SEC and B10 having more spots-I'm a bit of hater there. It would probably have to be done to get them to sign onto revenue sharing. I would want them to be limited to 4 spots only and a caveat that in this dream we are creating, if down the road other conferences who are getting equal money can compete now and the conference powers begin to shift or flatten.

I would add Item 8, money bonuses for players who compete in the playoffs depending on results and also even a loyalty payment for players who stay at one university for their 5-year plan. Would probably need to have a plan if coaches change on this one.
 
Anyone that has a financial stake in Big 12 ACC or Group of 5 teams, such as season ticket holders, etc

Should


File a Class Action lawsuit against the NCAA and CFP, naming ESPN, and the Television Providers, and others

RICO violation.

Do it.
 
football players have to go to ABET accredited classes.

Hell, we should just change this to "How do we fix "college" ". It has been broken since it was the preferred avenue of military deferments in the Vietnam era.
I'm about half serious: mandatory military service after high school for every citizen....then you can play foosball.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: FL Clone