Yeah, both are NBA PG size but neither have the handle or passing ability to play that position. And both are probably defensive liabilities. But that's where the comparison ends. McGee is a pure shooter where Wigginton is an attack the rim guy. LW's athleticism at least gives him a shot at the NBA someday. McGee was never going to play in the league.
I agree with all of this, and while Wigginton had a few highlight reel dunks, I do not recall him being a particularly
effective finisher around the rim through the trees. I remember a lot of turnovers that way. Sure, he definitely
tried to go to the rim far more than Tyrus ever did, but he was not really particularly good at it. Guys like Monté and Naz were much better at it within recent memory in the numbers for finding the right angle or window to finish at the rim.
At the rim shooting statistics, for comparison...
2019 Wigginton = 38/60 (63.3%, assisted 44.7%)
2017 Morris = 80/128 (62.5%, assisted 17.5%)
2017 Mitrou-Long = 79/104 (76.0, assisted 32.9%)
Filtering out the assisted shots, which are by definition not looks you created for yourself and likely relatively easy to finish, and you end up with the following...
2019 Wigginton = 21/43 (48.9%)
2017 Morris = 66/114 (57.9%)
2017 Mitrou-Long = 53/78 (68.0%)
Doing the same calculations for McGee...
2012 McGee = 21/29 (72.4%, assisted 28.6%)
2013 McGee = 33/43 (76.7%, assisted 39.4%)
Adjusting out the assisted ones...
2012 McGee = 14/22 (63.8%)
2013 McGee= 22/32 (68.9%)
Tyrus was not going to the rack as much as Wigginton, but not
that much less if you look at it, and he was much more efficient about when he did it. Ironically, the more I look here, the more the two are coming across as comparable. They were both ideal bench gunners who could can you three pointers but lacked PG skills and hurt you on defense. I know that might sound odd given the different level of athlete and their different paths to Ames (with Tyrus being a pretty unheralded JUCO and Wigginton being a near-5* recruit with tons of expectations), but looking this over, junior/senor Tyrus and sophomore Wigginton fit best into a similar niche.
Donovan Jackson would be another example of that bench gunner who could score in bunches but lacked the other guard skills (again, PG skills and defense) for the next level.
Ironically, despite some of our curiosities/worries about him coming in, Wigginton was at his best as a spot-up shooter. He shot 40.1% and 39.0% from three in his two years; McGee shot 39.4% and 46.4% in his two years. DJax went 45.4% as a junior (44/97) and 40.1% at a much higher volume as a senior (95/237, the school record is 102 by Deadeye Dedric in 1997).
Wigginton might have had ambitions of a more versatile offensive game, but the best part of it was still his shooting. McGee never had pretensions of being anything besides a shooter, but that was where they both excelled based on where they were most efficient.