Who was more "IN"?

[Die4Cy]

Congratulations Cyclones for being the only team to ever complete a season without losing a fumble. While an obscure team record, as far as I'm concerned, you own it all to yourselves!

And I thought the Seneca call was bad:

 

[CloneGuy8]

Seneca, because we lost that game

 

[cyclonedave25]

David and its not close, especially with the camera angles these days. I can honestly say without a doubt, he was across the goalline with the ball. I have only seen 2 angles of Seneca’s play and would not bet my life on him being in. Do I think he was? Yes, but would not bet my life on it.

 

[CycloneErik]

He's in the middle of the white painted square. That's pretty obviously across the goal line, since the painted squares were in the end zone.

So many ways to see how obvious that was. So few to call it a fumble.

 

[ArgentCy]

Easy, Montgomerys was a TD without fail. Until you let incompetent replay officials around. The game sucks anymore because no one wants to make a call. Those on the field don't blow a whistle because then it can't be reviewed sometimes and the stupid replay bozos just let things stand because it has to be obvious to a blind duck to overturn.

 

[19clone91]

And the rule states that just the very tip of the football has to cross the first white blade of grass to be a TD. Its outrageous that it was called a fumble on the field first of all, and even more ridiculous that it wasn't overturned.

 

[ISU_phoria]

I would have bet my life savings they were going to over turn that call.

Can you imagine the melt down here if we would have not won the game?!?! I'd be in full conspiracy mode, especially after the way the KState game went down!

Congrats Cyclones!! Awesome Year & well -deserved, especially for the seniors who put in 4-5 years of all they had! So happy for them!

 

[jkclone]

Three games this year where the officials clearly tried to hurt our chances. Thankfully we were able to overcome this one.

 

[ViktorLuzor]

OH what a bunch of conspiracy theorists you all are! It is CLEAR to anyone with a brain and at least one eye that both Wally and Monty were down by contact!!

 

[flycy]

The only possibility is they decided they could not conclusively decide he had possession after the bobbled hand off. Never mind he regained control, took a few steps and reached across the goal line with the ball solidly in two hands. And why weren't a couple questionable catches by Memphis reviewed?

 

[veteran4cy]

Both were bad considering I have the photo that proves Seneca was in but they didn't have the camera angles, definition or replay that they did today. So i would have to say DM

 

[3TrueFans]

Three games this year where the officials clearly tried to hurt our chances. Thankfully we were able to overcome this one.

I haven't been following threads most of the day, did we all agree to just ignore the roughing the passer call that gave us a touchdown?

 

[FinalFourCy]

I haven't been following threads most of the day, did we all agree to just ignore the roughing the passer call that gave us a touchdown?

It was a subjective call, one that I disagree with, but that’s football now. There’s nothing to dispute.

Nothing is subjective about DM being in for the TD.

 

[3TrueFans]

It was a subjective call, one that I disagree with, but that’s football now. There’s nothing to dispute.

Nothing is subjective about DM being in for the TD.

Ok, just checking that we're ignoring that.

 

[HFCS]

Seneca call probably had to stand with call on the field even if we had replay then.

Montgomery was a full yard in when he lost the ball, one of the most baffling calls ever. I really can't even understand getting that wrong live, but to then review it and be a FULL YARD OFF in your review is just ridiculous.

 

[Cyhops]

The main point is that we didn't let a bad call define the game for us. We overcame and won. Don't forget the Memphis interception overturned for a questionable penalty for roughing the qb

 

[Beyerball]

For a bowl game that replay booth was horrid..heck how can u not look at Butler tight rope sideline TD waved off.

Butler very well may been out but man that foot was darn close

 

[casey1973]

Not even close, he was in by a foot. You just knew whatever was called on the field they weren't going to over turn it. A lot of bodies in the way and a couple angles weren't conclusive but one was clear that he was in.

 

[HFCS]

I haven't been following threads most of the day, did we all agree to just ignore the roughing the passer call that gave us a touchdown?

99% of us agreed it was a bad call and huge break live.

I can understand blowing DM’s TD score live, would have been same kind of mistake.

Holding up that call on replay is something different though. He had broken the plane by a yard when he lost control.

 

[FinalFourCy]

Ok, just checking that we're ignoring that.

Like, I said, there’s nothing to ignore. Next question.