As far as basketball, everybody else has nailed it. Fran's inability to recruit is killing UNI. UNI had Pemsl and Kriener in the bag until Fran came way late and dangled being a Hawk and playing in the Big 10 in front of them. Those two front court guys alone to go with UNIs guards make them the best team in the Valley this year. Throw in Phyfe missing the year and injuries to Pickford and Goldman and that's why UNI has been inconsistent. Green is going to be the best player in UNI history and is on pace to destroy the all time scoring record but is still kind of forcing things due to not having a great supporting cast. He'll be Valley POY in the future and he would have certainly seen minutes at Iowa State or Virginia this year if he'd decided to leave Cedar Falls.
From a department wide perspective we're on our second consecutive poor AD. Troy Dannen was a disaster that tried to run the department like he was still running the Girl's Union and had absolutely no big dreams or aspirations but did get the budget under control. Now David Harris can dream big and fund raises well but he has no earthly idea what he's doing as far as running a major college athletic program on a day to day basis. Had a staff mutiny that led to every other experienced person in the department to just flat out quit.
Football is what it is. Farley is a marvelous recruiter that has some of the best talent at the FCS level but, a lot like Paul Rhodes, can't get out of the way of his staff on game day and tries to control everything. Dannen also saddled him with the toughest FCS schedule in the country year in and year out. I've been in the Fire Farley crowd but, at the same time, I'm not sure you do much better unless you're okay with revolving door of young coaches.
Well, I don't know if I'm the most visible dual ISU/UNI fan on here, but I know I've mentioned many times before that I am one, which I make no apologies for, so I almost feel obligated to answer the OP.
Can't speak much to the inner workings of the AD with me living in Colorado, so I'll defer to 1UNI2ISU on that one. I do know that Troy Dannen had more than worn out his welcome by the time he left.
For football, count me in as one of the fans who wants Farley gone; this last season I ended up paying almost no attention to the results, since we (UNI) got blown out in the very first game of the season, which follows past seasons trends of getting our a$$ kicked against a good but beatable non-conference opponent, winning a game we have no business winning, followed up by losing a game we have no business losing, which ends up in hosting a first round game in the playoffs against an overmatched team, before going on the road and losing in the second round. Rinse, repeat, recycle, season after season. It gets old, and I'm ready for a change. However, as long as he wins just enough I expect him to stay there.
As for basketball, I really can't add much more than what is written above, other than to write that the current junior class, IMO the source for most of the ills with UNI BB, was a much better class on paper than it's turned out to be so far. PG Juwan McCloud, who transferred to a Division II team, was a very good recruit who just didn't out. There goes someone that was relied upon to be the PG for three or four years. Luke McDonnell was getting some Big Ten interest, including from TOE, before he signed with UNI. He's having a decent season finally, but didn't see the floor much at all his first two years. The margin of error for MVC schools when it comes to misses in recruiting is much narrower than it is for Power 5 schools. I'm patient enough for now to want to give Ben Jacobson the chance to dig the program out of the hole it's currently in, as I do think he's the best coach in UNI history, and it's not even close, but the program is clearly trending downward, and if we 3-8 versus Division I competition in the non-conference next year the way we did this season, I think his seat will get hot and deservedly so. I'm not happy with this season, but the only senior is Wyatt Lohaus, so most of the pieces are coming back with a decent recruiting class coming in.