I'll admit I really enjoy LOTR, but had to like this post.
*Edit - Will also add my submission with The Boondock Saints. That movie sucked.
An employee of mine traded favorite movies to watch that the other had never seen before. Hers for me to watch was Boondock Saints. Oh my God was it awful. Almost unbearable to watch. Dafoe's character started out promising but then quickly deteriorated to garbage.