This is simple. The likes of Paul Rhoads, Kirk Ferentz and Wally Burnham seem to think its critical, so mark me for it 100%.
A surgeon should decide what he or she thinks is essential to complete his or her task, not some administrators. Same thing here.
I wish more people would think like this. Let the people that do the job for a living decide what is best. If you think your idea is better, get the job and try it your way.