I’ve never understood nor been a proponent of that. The dude is killing you, so you attack him when he can’t retaliate? Just stop sucking as a pitching staff and figure out how to get the dude out. If you can’t do that, take the bat out of his hands and walk him.
Right now it feels like MIL has a 75% chance of scoring every time he steps to the plate. Play the odds and walk him.
This.
Feels like a Matheny thing to do, to not walk him.