Mike McCarthy Fired From Green Bay

runbikeswim

Well-Known Member
Oct 23, 2014
2,079
1,472
83
Living here in WI for the last 12 years, I can say in all honesty, it has amazed me how the Packer fan base has been critical of him since day 1. The man was head coach of an NFL team that has been to the playoffs 9 of the last 12 years, and a superbowl. One of the perennial teams always in the discussion. I'm not saying it wasn't the right time or decision, but the problems in Green Bay are deeper than the HC. IMO, not having Jordy Nelson (injury then gone) was a huge loss for them. He was clutch.
 

STATE12

Well-Known Member
Jul 8, 2015
448
433
63
Living here in WI for the last 12 years, I can say in all honesty, it has amazed me how the Packer fan base has been critical of him since day 1. The man was head coach of an NFL team that has been to the playoffs 9 of the last 12 years, and a superbowl. One of the perennial teams always in the discussion. I'm not saying it wasn't the right time or decision, but the problems in Green Bay are deeper than the HC. IMO, not having Jordy Nelson (injury then gone) was a huge loss for them. He was clutch.

Almost as if GB fans don't know what it's like to not be in contention for the division/playoffs every year. Becomes the expectation every year, and maybe have lost sight of how spoiled they have been for the (mostly) seamless transition from the Favre era and this far into the Rodgers.

Luckily for me, I'm a Vikings and Cyclones fan so I've been often reminded how special the great years can be! :D
 

Bubbahotep

Well-Known Member
Jul 23, 2008
5,229
3,571
113
56
Des Moines
Their biggest problem for years has been injuries. Their strength and conditioning program has got to be one of the worst in the NFL.
 

Bubbahotep

Well-Known Member
Jul 23, 2008
5,229
3,571
113
56
Des Moines
Almost as if GB fans don't know what it's like to not be in contention for the division/playoffs every year. Becomes the expectation every year, and maybe have lost sight of how spoiled they have been for the (mostly) seamless transition from the Favre era and this far into the Rodgers.

Luckily for me, I'm a Vikings and Cyclones fan so I've been often reminded how special the great years can be! :D
I remember the 70's and 80's well, especially when their #1 pick bolted for the CFL rather than play in Green Bay. It's been a nice run, but when you have two of the all-time QB's for 25 years, you probably should win more than 2 Super Bowls. Ted Thompson's lousy draft picks the last few years doomed them, and McCarthy's unwillingness to be a little creative on the offensive end doomed himself.
 

IASTATE07

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
May 30, 2016
12,774
20,420
113
What does that have to do with anything? Anyway, are you surprised that Rodgers works to maintain a public image to maximize his earning potential? How does that make him any different than any other highly recognizable pro athlete? It isn't a sin.

I think he's difficult to work with sometimes, but you could say the same for nearly every great QB in the modern era. Those guys are famously competitive and stubborn. Peyton Manning got Jim Mora fired once upon a time. Belichick and Brady have a relationship you might call professional, but not close. They both know the score. Belichick will move on from Brady as soon as he slips, and if they weren't constantly winning and one guy had to go Kraft would pick Brtady over Belichick in a heartbeat.
McCarthy didn't get fired just because the QB/coach relationship deteriorated. His offense was starting to look downright primitive, and thirteen years is a long time for a coach to stay in one place. He got stale and to an extent he and Rodgers both were victims of poor roster construction. It was just a divorce that had to happen, and of course they were always going to keep the future hall of fame QB over the head coach.

That's not true.
 

Die4Cy

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2010
14,972
15,857
113
We'll see. A few years ago it looked like Drew Brees was going to end his career with a losing team or move on in free agency. One stellar draft later the Saints were serious contenders again. I'm not saying it will happen for the Packers, just saying it could. Things change quickly in the NFL.

I'll be curious how wide a net they cast for the next head coach. Rodgers would be an interesting challenge for a lot of coaches. He's one of the most talented quarterbacks I've ever seen, but he's also a very strong personality who can be difficult to work with. You almost need a playcaller who has no problem with taking the heat when things go south and deferring to Rodgers whenever things go well. For sheer entertainment purposes I'd love to see Arians land there. His aggressive scheme plus Rodgers' ability to improvise and make plays downfield would be fun to watch. And their personalities would clash hard. Endless entertainment.

In terms of fit, I would think an Arians hire would be a no-brainer for the Pack, but he seems to be leaning towards the Browns for some reason, if media accounts are worth anything.
 

SCyclone

Well-Known Member
Mar 11, 2014
9,475
12,233
113
Fort Dodge, IA
Interesting that McCarthy didn't get a sniff. I am thankful for his years in Green Bay, he kept his team competitive despite some poor drafts. Many will say he didn't win enough Super Bowls, but when your team is in the conversation pretty much every year, despite your QB using a great deal of the salary cap, and having to draft in high positions, that speaks volumes.

McCarthy still has more rings than Zimmer. Or Frazier. Or Childress. Or Tice. Or Green. Or.....should I go on?
 

jbindm

Well-Known Member
Dec 2, 2010
13,073
7,605
113
Des Moines
Interesting that McCarthy didn't get a sniff. I am thankful for his years in Green Bay, he kept his team competitive despite some poor drafts. Many will say he didn't win enough Super Bowls, but when your team is in the conversation pretty much every year, despite your QB using a great deal of the salary cap, and having to draft in high positions, that speaks volumes.

McCarthy still has more rings than Zimmer. Or Frazier. Or Childress. Or Tice. Or Green. Or.....should I go on?

I was kind of surprised that he didn't get all that much interest. He must have a lot of friends in the national media, because when he got fired the general opinion seemed to be that he'd be one of the top candidates for another opening. I never got the impression that he's sitting out the 2019 season by choice.
 

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron