Iowa Football Recruiting

[CyTwins]

Right now KF has accomplished more so yes. Now if Herman exceeds KF accomplishments at some point in the future then we can talk.

Lol I can't believe you think Ferentz is a better coach than Tom Herman. Wow!

 

[BCClone]

Not if you are basing on accomplishments. KF has more New Years Six appearances

Is KF the best Iowa football coach because of NY6 games?

 

[Walmartthieves]

Lol I can't believe you think Ferentz is a better coach than Tom Herman. Wow!

What has Herman accomplished as a HC that exceeds KF?

 

[JP4CY]

Lol I can't believe you think Ferentz is a better coach than Tom Herman. Wow!

Herman is a summers eve but I was shocked how he coached circles around Kirby Smart.
Now in the grand scheme, I'd lean towards taking Kirby over him but it was eye opening.

 

[CyTwins]

What has Herman accomplished as a HC that exceeds KF?

You're probably the only person in the world that thinks Kirk Ferentz is a better coach than Tom Herman

 

[JP4CY]

What has Herman accomplished as a HC that exceeds KF?

It apparently will never sink into you that there's a difference in accomplishment and better.

You are trying too hard.

 

[Walmartthieves]

Herman is a summers eve but I was shocked how he coached circles around Kirby Smart.
Now in the grand scheme, I'd lean towards taking Kirby over him but it was eye opening.

I wouldn’t base coaching ability from the outcome of one game but that is just me.

Herman is 0-2 against Maryland.

 

[JP4CY]

I wouldn’t base coaching ability from the outcome of one game but that is just me.

Herman is 0-2 against Maryland.

How did Kirk start out his career against ISU?

 

[Walmartthieves]

How did Kirk start out his career against ISU?

How is Kirk now? Like I said If Herman accomplishes more than KF in the future I will say he is a better coach. Right now your “better” is in the eye of the beholder without the results to back it up.

 

[JP4CY]

How is Kirk now? Like I said If Herman accomplishes more than KF in the future I will say he is a better coach. Right now your “better” is in the eye of the beholder without the results to back it up.

You are trying to have it both ways and are using possible future results to figure out who is a better coach now.

 

[Walmartthieves]

You are trying to have it both ways and are using possible future results to figure out who is a better coach now.

No I am saying results as of now says KF has accomplished more than Herman. Thus KF is better coach right now. If that changes in the future and Herman accomplishes more than KF then the conclusion would change as well.

 

[BillBrasky4Cy]

No I am saying results as of now says KF has accomplished more than Herman. Thus KF is better coach right now. If that changes in the future and Herman accomplishes more than KF then the conclusion would change as well.

Yeah... it doesn't really work that way...

 

[JP4CY]

No I am saying results as of now says KF has accomplished more than Herman. Thus KF is better coach right now. If that changes in the future and Herman accomplishes more than KF then the conclusion would change as well.

So future accomplishes will determine if Herman is a better coach now?

You are interesting.

 

[JP4CY]

Yeah... it doesn't really work that way...

He's using "results of now" when the comparison is like 25 years vs 5 and saying that makes someone a better coach. Very weird.

 

[BillBrasky4Cy]

He's using "results of now" when the comparison is like 25 years vs 5 and saying that makes someone a better coach. Very weird.

Yeah... Thinker has said some pretty stupid **** on here but claiming that coaching is static because of old accomplishments has gotta be right up there.

 

[Cat Stevens]

If you are so confident in your argument go to the BOR with it. In fact demand that they re-open the investigation with your information or you will go to the media and claim this is exactly like Penn State. If that doesn’t get their attention I am sure there are media outlets that would love to go on an Iowa witch-hunt with you.

First you’re still a piece of **** for being happy about protecting the program and destroying a girls life.

Second, provide your real name, and state that you are calling the girl and her parents liars.

Third, they already did that and the bor bought a report to clear them.

Fourth, and I will repeat that you guys being ok with rape cover up makes you **** **** people.

 

[CyTwins]

Herky thinks Kevin Ollie is one of the best basketball coaches on the planet

 

[ribsnwhiskey]

I suppose it's better than nothing, but found it funny that Stanley is known as "The Mel Kiper Guy". FWIW, I think he does have NFL talent, but man is it sporadic.

The Mel Kiper Guy
Nathan Stanley, Iowa, Sr

• Mel Kiper is a trailblazer in the NFL media scout industry, but Kiper has lost his touch and will always bang the table for a random QB. Jimmy Clausen was an all-timer in this category, but this year it looks like his guy is Nathan Stanley. There are things to like with Stanley. He’s got size, size, and more size, but he’s lacking a ton. With his mechanical flaws, lack of poise, and inaccuracy, particularly on deep balls, he’s far from being more than a late-round QB prospect. Stanley needs to become a consistent short to intermediate passer this season. Right now he’s an NFL backup type.
• Pro Comparison: Chad Henne

https://armchairallamericans.com/the-armchair-scout-an-early-look-at-the-qbs-in-the-2020-nfl-draft/

Fixed

 

[dexterhawk]

The season can’t get here fast enough.

Really taking a toll on this board...

 

[JP4CY]

Yeah... Thinker has said some pretty stupid **** on here but claiming that coaching is static because of old accomplishments has gotta be right up there.

Yeah, I mean Butch Davis has won a National Title but I'd still rather have CMC here.