I was not a fan when they were popular but now appreciate them as being an awesome band. Enzinger is super underrated as a guitarist. Lots of cool riffs with some subtle intricacies. It looks like he went over every chord and tried to see if there was a different voicing or add he could use. Plus some of chords he used took some serious stretch. My opinion on playing a lot of His riffs is that you can get relatively close and fake it fairly easily. It will sound decent. But to really nail it, it is pretty damn hard.
I don't play anything so I can't appreciate it from a technical musicianship standpoint, but I love their unique melodies/harmonies and rhythms. Good lyrics too. They're just a really, really good band.
Maybe that's it - I like to sing along with all their stuff, but none of it quite crosses that threshold of "incredible-have-to-own-it" for me. Like the 90s Buffalo Bills, going to the Super Bowl four straight years but never winning it. Then you look back and realize those guys were still really ******* good.