Do you know the timeline of events. No. None of us do. None of us probably ever will. How do you know Cael didn't say "I'm applying for the Penn State offer." JP says "Ok." Cael doesn't say anything about getting the offer, walks into JP with his resignation, saying he's accepting the offer and there's nothing we can do to keep him here.
I appreciate you helping me to make my point.
There is only one way that Cael doesn't let Iowa State counter offer and that is b/c he doesn't want to work for JP anymore. The guy loves Iowa State to much to just leave w/o giving us a chance