Yes, but that doesn't mean that a coach can't look at them and say, hey he would fit well in my non pro-style system. However they rank in that format is fairly irrelevant to Campbell most likely because we don't run that.
All Iowa Football Team---Post Bowl Edition
- Thread starter YeahBuddy
- Start date
Yes, but that doesn't mean that a coach can't look at them and say, hey he would fit well in my non pro-style system. However they rank in that format is fairly irrelevant to Campbell most likely because we don't run that.
No I didn't. I was responding to the ridiculous post that said ISU wouldn't have taken Stanley if given the chance by pointing out that Stanley was a much higher rated QB recruit, same style, with better offers than Noland. So saying ISU wouldn't have wanted him when they took a lower rated pro-style QB recruit is just dumb. Stanley's on-field performance this year is what makes him better than Zeb at this point.
Still not understanding why a spread offense team cares about pro-style recruit ranking.
Lanning lost his position to the guy who got outplayed by Stanley in Ames.
Park didn’t win the job because of deep throws. It’s just the truth that Lanning throws a better deep ball.
PLUS: (possibly referenced within the thread, haven't made it all the way through):
ESPN Total BQ rating
17. Kyle Kempt
69. Nathan Stanley
I'm no expert about QBR calculation, but if the gap is that large — advantage Kempt.
Lanning is a fun debate. Kempt was obviously better than Stanley.
If you put Lanning in an offense like KSU’s I think he’s the best in the whole debate. He’s the best runner in the argument by far and throws a good deep ball, his accuracy on short and intermediate was the issue. I was never the biggest Park fan to be honest, convince me Stanley is a dependable person and I’d take him over Park.
I don’t get it. If Wadley & Stanley are so good, why did Iowa rank 116th in total offense? Sure, 1 game versus the good guys they over perform, but then 15 pass attempts in the bowl? 15? And 2 to WRs?
ISU ran over 60 more plays than Iowa this year in the same number of games. That’s like another whole game. ISU passed as much as Iowa ran the ball. What position Iowa have the most difficulty recruiting again?
But hey, program changing bowl win. Half the hock fans were trying to eat the other half on Twitter & other social media during that game but Buttbuddy, Geezer, & other shitstain hocks like to mention here about how great things are & future being beyond bright. To each their own
ISU ran over 60 more plays than Iowa this year in the same number of games. That’s like another whole game. ISU passed as much as Iowa ran the ball. What position Iowa have the most difficulty recruiting again?
But hey, program changing bowl win. Half the hock fans were trying to eat the other half on Twitter & other social media during that game but Buttbuddy, Geezer, & other shitstain hocks like to mention here about how great things are & future being beyond bright. To each their own
Stanley did throw an inaccurate deep ball but he could throw a nice 20-25 yard strike all over the field, and you throw a lot more of those than deep balls. He did improve on the deep ball accuracy.
Its the same thing that holds ISU back the most, the offensive line. Iowa played the most of the year with 2 freshmen starting OT's. Montgomery is obviously better suited to break tackles but Wadley was still a very good back. Don't forget who made a huge play or two at the end of the Iowa vs ISU game to put the game in OT.
This is pretty dumb considering what just transpired with two DE recruits in this very state in the class of 2018.
Brian Ferentz and as much as I make fun of NFL Stanley didn't help him by being so inaccurate
No, the reason for optimism is because in year one at Iowa KF won 1 game. In year two he won 3 games. Campbell won 3 in year one, and 8 in year two. 4 wins for KF in his first two years at Iowa, and 11 wins for Campbell in his first two years at ISU.
So in year 2 at ISU, Campbell won as many games at KF did in year 19 at Iowa.
So NY 6 Bowl game and undefeated Big 12 season in Year 4 or bust, right?
Stanley is much younger than Kempt and has a much bigger arm and led a demolition of Ohio State. Your argument here sucks.
And LOL at the moral victory of almost beating Okie State.
You use AP first if teams are listed in the Top 25 there and then resort to Sagarin if not. Iowa finished #9 in the final poll for the 2015 season.
