I totally agree. Those years we made it to the Independence Bowl, I was dying to make it to the Alamo. All we probably had to do was win one more game. Just one... I wouldn't go to Sheveport, but I'd go to San Antonio.
In 2001, it was other Big Ten teams that prevented ISU from going to San Antonio.
On Nov. 24:
Penn State beat Michigan State, 42-37
After Nov. 24:
Purdue (6-4, 4-4)
Iowa (6-5, 4-4)
Penn State (5-5, 4-4)
Michigan State (5-5, 3-5)
On Dec. 1:
Purdue loses to Notre Dame, drops to 6-5
Penn State loses to Virginia, drops to 5-6
Michigan State beats Missouri, improves to 6-5
All of that allowed Iowa to slide up the pecking order. And since the Alamo wasn't going to touch an ISU/Iowa rematch (especially since the teams played on Nov. 24), Iowa went to San Antonio to play Texas Tech, and ISU went to Shreveport to play Alabama.
2001 Big 12 Standings (pre-bowl):
Colorado (10-2, 7-1; Big 12 Champ) -- FIESTA
Texas (10-2, 7-1; Big 12 South winner) -- HOLIDAY
Nebraska (11-1, 7-1) -- ROSE (BCS title game)
Oklahoma (10-2, 6-2) -- COTTON
Texas A&M (7-4, 4-4) -- HOUSTON (galleryfurniture.com)
Iowa State (6-5, 4-4) -- INDEPENDENCE
Texas Tech (6-5, 4-4) -- ALAMO
Kansas State (6-5, 3-5) -- INSIGHT
ISU wasn't going to play in the Insight, after being there in 2000.
A&M wasn't going to play in the Independence, after being there in 2000, or likely the Alamo (1999 appearance).
Tech wasn't going to Houston, after being there in 2000.
The prevailing thought (until Dec. 1) was: A&M to Houston, ISU to Alamo, Tech to Independence.