49ers - Brock Purdy - Still and Always #1

NorthCyd

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 22, 2011
18,004
28,653
113
The Chiefs look just like they did last year. Look at last year's schedule. They played in close games all year. Not too worried about style points in a random October game.
giphy.webp
 

ghyland7

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 8, 2012
564
1,416
93
Burrow is the 2nd best QB in the league.
Justin Herbert has zero playoff wins.

Trevor Lawrence has one playoff win.

Lamar Jackson has one playoff win.

Aaron Rodgers has a torn Achilles and isn’t playing this year.

Joe Burrow is great! Mahomes is great!

Josh Allen has 4 playoff wins.

Let’s just assume that you think it’s Mahomes, Burrow, and Allen.

Who else is so superior to Lamar? Jalen Hurts? Kyler (also injured)? Stafford? Dak?

Many of the top guys are rated such on potential (Lawrence, Herbert), and many of the other guys are injured (Kyler, Rodgers).
 

deadeyededric

Well-Known Member
Dec 12, 2009
14,690
12,504
113
Parts Unknown
Justin Herbert has zero playoff wins.

Trevor Lawrence has one playoff win.

Lamar Jackson has one playoff win.

Aaron Rodgers has a torn Achilles and isn’t playing this year.

Joe Burrow is great! Mahomes is great!

Josh Allen has 4 playoff wins.

Let’s just assume that you think it’s Mahomes, Burrow, and Allen.

Who else is so superior to Lamar? Jalen Hurts? Kyler (also injured)? Stafford? Dak?

Many of the top guys are rated such on potential (Lawrence, Herbert), and many of the other guys are injured (Kyler, Rodgers).
They also have multiple years of putting up great numbers. Not 6 games.
 

ghyland7

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 8, 2012
564
1,416
93
I'd say like 6 or 7
you've said only Mahomes and Burrow. Who else is the top 5?

moreover, I explicitly asked about Lamar Jackson but you responded about Purdy, saying he has played only 6 games. why are you so obsessed with discrediting Brock? He has 2 playoff wins and has started 13 games including postseason. Even if you want to count the eagles loss against him, AND you want to ignore the miami game where he came in during the first quarter, he has more than double the experience you give him credit for. Why?

I, like any other rational person on this thread, don't think that Purdy is better than Mahomes. Nobody puts Mahomes anywhere other than first on their list of NFL QBs. Does giving Purdy credit somehow discredit Mahomes?

And, if you just truly don't believe he is a good quarterback, then why in the hell are you trying to be a stick in the mud on an Iowa State fanpage shitting on the kid?
 

AllInForISU

Well-Known Member
Nov 24, 2012
3,119
3,126
113
you've said only Mahomes and Burrow. Who else is the top 5?

moreover, I explicitly asked about Lamar Jackson but you responded about Purdy, saying he has played only 6 games. why are you so obsessed with discrediting Brock? He has 2 playoff wins and has started 13 games including postseason. Even if you want to count the eagles loss against him, AND you want to ignore the miami game where he came in during the first quarter, he has more than double the experience you give him credit for. Why?

I, like any other rational person on this thread, don't think that Purdy is better than Mahomes. Nobody puts Mahomes anywhere other than first on their list of NFL QBs. Does giving Purdy credit somehow discredit Mahomes?

And, if you just truly don't believe he is a good quarterback, then why in the hell are you trying to be a stick in the mud on an Iowa State fanpage shitting on the kid?

He’s trying to make himself feel better about watching the best QB in the NFL put up one TD against the worst defense in the league. The only team the Chiefs played with a pulse they lost to and have squeaked by every other team except the horrible bears.
 

AuH2O

Well-Known Member
Sep 7, 2013
11,361
17,400
113
John Elway didn't get the credit he deserved until he won a Super Bowl. Dan Marino has a huge knock on him since he didn't. This isn't new.
So we are applying how stupid people evaluate QBs? Anyone that elevated Elway after the SB wins is an idiot. He was f’ing terrible in the first SB win. Terrible. He was decent in the second one playing a joke of a Falcons team that had no business being there.
 

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron