Yeah stories like this are just hard to imagine, definitely today. Luckily my company is pretty lax on time off, but as a supervisor, I've not yet declined any PTO requests. My stance is if you've earned the time (and aren't taking advantage at the disadvantage of others) - take some time for you. If/when someone above me has a problem with it, I'll gladly defend my choice to approve.
So, I have a question for you about PTO. I used to go round and round with my old boss about this. My brother was getting married at Christmas time a few years ago. A huge number of relatives were flying in, and it was going to be a whole week of celebrating. The wedding was a couple hours away, so I had planned on spending the week with my family at the site of the wedding.
And so, 6 months before, I submitted a PTO request for the week between Christmas and New year's. I tentatively put it on the vacation calendar, and thought I'd be good to go.
Well, my PTO request sat unapproved for months. I reminded my boss a few times but he told me not to worry about. November 1st rolls up and two more people on my team request the same week off. Now, my boss sees there's an issue and tells us we can't all have the time off, and that we need to figure it out.
I went to my coworkers and explained my situation. One of them said that he wanted to go out of town for the holidays. And the other said "well, I take that week off every year. It's tradition". Nobody wanted to budge. We went back to the boss, and he said "you guys figure it out"
Again, we talked about it, and nobody was willing to cancel their plans. I pointed out that I hadn't taken extra time off around Christmas in about 4 years, and backed it up with data from the vacation calendar. The second guy hadn't taken time off during Christmas for a couple years, and true to his word, the third guy had taken Christmas week off every year for as far back as the vacation calendar went.
Still, nobody would budge.
Armed with the vacation calendar data, we went back to the boss. He looked at the data, considered it for a bit, and said "You guys figure it out"
Effectively, he said that it wasn't a matter for management. I pointed out that I was pretty sure that conflict resolution was in fact a function of management. And we had a ****ing conflict. He didn't see it that way.
In the end, I ended up driving back from the wedding site to work two days, the second guy did the same, and the third guy took the full week off, just like tradition dictated.
I get that staff should be able to work out a schedule, but when there is a conflict like that, that's exactly what management is there for
What's funny, is I really liked my boss. We got along really well, and he was a great manager, whom I had a fantastic rapport with. We just didn't agree on this. We would joke about it quite a bit and give each other grief about it, but neither of us ever saw the other's perspective