More Difficult: Softball or Baseball

  • After Iowa State won the Big 12, a Cyclone made a wonderful offer to We Will that now increases our match. Now all gifts up to $400,000 between now and the Final 4 will be matched. Please consider giving at We Will Collective.
    This notice can be dismissed using the upper right corner X button.

Softball or Baseball


  • Total voters
    77

agcy68

Well-Known Member
Feb 9, 2007
2,551
786
113
76
Iowa
Got in to an interesting discussion at work if SB or BB is more difficult to play. Thoughts?
 

ISUTex

Well-Known Member
May 25, 2012
8,420
7,922
113
Rural U.S.A.
I'm gonna go with baseball. Just based on the differences in distance from the mound, fences, bases, arm strength, swinging power, size of ball etc. Imagine if college or pro baseball players trained to play softball? Yikes.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: BWRhasnoAC

MeowingCows

Well-Known Member
Jun 1, 2015
35,529
33,820
113
Iowa
Ball pace, travel, distances, and I feel like general variability (which related to ball speed and playing area size, too) are all higher in baseball than softball to me, so I'd go with baseball being generally more difficult to play.
 

heitclone

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jun 21, 2009
15,456
12,569
113
44
Way up there
Baseball, even the physical requirements are different. Just the difference in the physical impact on pitchers is probably enough to separate the two.
 

cyadict

Well-Known Member
Aug 4, 2006
814
341
63
Ankeny
I find baseball horribly boring to watch. With the shorter distances between bases in softball, the game seems faster to me. Much harder to turn a double play in softball with the bases being closer too..
 

SouthJerseyCy

Well-Known Member
Sep 6, 2008
1,639
1,620
113
55
Depends a whole hell of a lot what you mean by "more difficult". They are different sports. More difficult for the offense or defense? Pitching? Hitting? Fielding? Speed? Power? Strategy?
 
  • Agree
Reactions: SayMyName

ISUTex

Well-Known Member
May 25, 2012
8,420
7,922
113
Rural U.S.A.
I find baseball horribly boring to watch. With the shorter distances between bases in softball, the game seems faster to me. Much harder to turn a double play in softball with the bases being closer too..


Maybe, but the ball gets to the middle infielders faster, and they don't have to throw as far to first base. And a big softball is easier to field, handle and throw.
 

BCClone

Well Seen Member.
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 4, 2011
61,413
55,959
113
Not exactly sure.
I would say baseball because I’m softball a dominant pitcher can take you a long ways whereas in baseball they can only pitch maybe a third of the time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: heitclone

cyfanatic13

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 19, 2008
11,041
9,660
113
I think baseball is significantly harder but don’t have enough experience with softball to make a fair judgment. I’ve umped both quite a bit but without playing it’s hard to say. Although I did go yard off our high school’s borderline all state softball pitcher when I was a junior and I was NOT a good hitter
 

Doc

This is it Morty
Aug 6, 2006
37,437
21,962
113
Denver
I think softball is easier defensively both infield and outfield, BUT there is more room for error in baseball. I've never hit a fast-pitch softball pitcher so no idea there.
 

ISUTex

Well-Known Member
May 25, 2012
8,420
7,922
113
Rural U.S.A.
Check out the myriad of YouTube videos documenting the humiliation of many baseball players' attempts to hit a fastpitch softball, and I think you'll find your answer.

Paging @harimad for input on this thread.


Ok, take a softball player, and have them hit off of a top major league pitcher who throws a wicked cutter or a high 90's heater.

Once those baseball players got used to the rising action of the big yellow softball, they would be hitting pop flies 50 feet beyond the little league fences.
 

heitclone

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jun 21, 2009
15,456
12,569
113
44
Way up there
Check out the myriad of YouTube videos documenting the humiliation of many baseball players' attempts to hit a fastpitch softball, and I think you'll find your answer.

Paging @harimad for input on this thread.

I always thought it'd be neat to see this the other way around. FWIW, I don't think this answers anything about difficulty. It's one sided/half-assed way to make softball seem tougher, the softball ladies wouldn't fair much better against men pitching either I'd guess. Things like this don't tell you much other than demonstrate how different the two sports are.
 

heitclone

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jun 21, 2009
15,456
12,569
113
44
Way up there
Ok, take a softball player, and have them hit off of a top major league pitcher who throws a wicked cutter or a high 90's heater.

Once those baseball players got used to the rising action of the big yellow softball, they would be hitting pop flies 50 feet beyond the little league fences.

Agree, not sure what's convincing about seeing someone try to do something they've never done before.
 

Tre4ISU

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 30, 2008
27,841
8,549
113
Estherville
I think softball is easier defensively both infield and outfield, BUT there is more room for error in baseball. I've never hit a fast-pitch softball pitcher so no idea there.

When I was in around 8th or 9th grade, I tried to hit off what was considered a very good high school softball pitcher. It was very hard but mostly because the delivery was so much different that I couldn't get a feel. The ball didn't seem to be hard to hit but I don't think I was picking it up the same. FWIW, I was pretty decent at making contact. Wasn't a great hitter but made contact a lot.

I'd say baseball. If it weren't, you'd see women making their way to baseball, I think.

As for the video mentioned above, if you give those guys a week to see softball pitching, that video's going to look different.
 

jbindm

Well-Known Member
Dec 2, 2010
13,073
7,604
113
Des Moines
I didn't play either in high school. But I played enough little league to know that I'm a ****** baseball player. My wife was an all-state softball pitcher in high school and would have pitched in college if not for back problems.
Just once for the hell of it I had her throw me a few pitches just to see if I could get a bat on one of them. I couldn't. Even as big as the damn softball is, the speed and movement of it coming from that close of a range make it irrelevant. It could have been the size of a beach ball and I wouldn't have managed much more than a foul tip. Conclusion: From a batting perspective they're both really, really difficult.