GPS Devices - Good, Bad or Indifferent?

Angie

Tugboats and arson.
Staff member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 27, 2006
28,591
13,590
113
IA
My Garmin 255 is farking awesome. Route recalculation is sweet.....I can turn away from heavy traffic (or if I just want to take another route) and it will instantly recalculate. Gives the estimated arrival time, current speed, and will zoom in when I approach complex intersections where I need to make a turn.

The voice is annoying, but what computerized voice isn't? The menus for finding restaurants and entertainment are sweet. I wasn't expecting those listings to be as in-depth as they are.

Sounds like you're not using the sexy British dude. :wink: You can actually download additional voices and arrow pointers from the Garmin website - some Christmas- and Halloween-themed stuff.

My husband got me a Garmin 255w as part of my Christmas present, and I love it. Like others have said, it just has great features. The nearby attractions are great, it recognizes businesses when you spell them out, different views of the road...
 
Last edited:

cyman1189

Well-Known Member
Aug 11, 2008
1,659
99
48
35
Akron, OH
i think they are dumb, if u dont know where something is, isnt it worth just google mapping it opposed to spending 100+$$$? i mean i understand why people get them, but i i dont think i ever see myself getting one
 

cytech

Well-Known Member
Apr 10, 2006
6,480
242
63
Hiawatha, Iowa
i think they are dumb, if u dont know where something is, isnt it worth just google mapping it opposed to spending 100+$$$? i mean i understand why people get them, but i i dont think i ever see myself getting one

People like myself that run service businesses find them very useful when traveling to client's homes for either work or bidding. Having a GPS has saved me hours of work weekly. And has paid for itself long ago.

Also I want to add that I find myself still using google maps first, just to get a general idea on the location of a home if I have no clue going ahead of time.
As has been mentioned the GPS does not always know the fastest way.
 
Last edited:

Angie

Tugboats and arson.
Staff member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 27, 2006
28,591
13,590
113
IA
i think they are dumb, if u dont know where something is, isnt it worth just google mapping it opposed to spending 100+$$$? i mean i understand why people get them, but i i dont think i ever see myself getting one

Reading directions from a paper while driving is vastly less safe than using a GPS. I travel a great deal for work and drive on unfamiliar roads - I usually used Mapquest until we started getting Neverlost through work, and it was very unsafe.
 

alaskaguy

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2006
10,203
220
63
I own two GPS devices; the Garmin Forerunner 305 (for workouts) and another Garmin GPS for my vehicle (not sure of the model #). Both were well worth the investment. In fact, I trust the Garmin in my vehicle far more than I do maps in routing myself to new locations.

They are invaluable IMO.
 
Last edited:

alaskaguy

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2006
10,203
220
63
i think they are dumb, if u dont know where something is, isnt it worth just google mapping it opposed to spending 100+$$$? i mean i understand why people get them, but i i dont think i ever see myself getting one
I find that they are very cheap. Especially compared to a lot of other gadgets like cell phones (which I don't own), televisions, etc.

A GPS device has saved my life on probably more than one occasion snowmachining and/or hiking in Alaska. It is so easy to lose your coordinates/location hiking in remote/wilderness areas. In these cases having a GPS device in my possession saved me.
 
Last edited:

isucy86

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2006
9,132
7,732
113
Dubuque
Planning a Trip to Europe this Summer

I am going to Europe this summer and had thought about getting a GPS to help find my way to different tourist attractions/lodging/ restaurants. I haven't done any research.

Do GPS work well outside the US and are they also helpful if someone is walking instead of in a car?

TIA
 

cytech

Well-Known Member
Apr 10, 2006
6,480
242
63
Hiawatha, Iowa
Most of the cheaper models are sold with generally only US maps. Some include canada or mexico too. But I imagine you can buy different maps for them just not sure.
 

dustinal

Well-Known Member
Nov 14, 2006
3,631
186
63
My dad has a Garmin, he loves it.

Ever since I was a kid, I have LOVED reading maps when we travel. Can't see myself ever buying a GPS just because of this quirky little passion that I have. I guess it's part of having a great "sense" of direction wherever I am. But to each his own. I know a lot of people w/ GPS systems, they all seem to like whichever ones they own.

I understand your love for reading maps. I did the same thing when I was a kid. The problem now is that I usually end up doing the driving, and I don't trust the people who ride with me to read the maps. (Most of the people who ride with me can't even seem to read a Google Maps printout correctly.) So for that reason, I'd really like to have a GPS. My parents have a Garmin that I've used a little bit, so I'd like to have one of those too.
 

OWLCITYCYFAN

Well-Known Member
Sep 6, 2006
2,637
1,977
113
Iowa City
I have the 260w and am very satisfied. Do not settle for a smaller screen. It costs about $70 to upgrade maps each year but I turn it in as an expense. The restaurant feature is great and so is the casino finder. Don't bother getting one with more features than a 260 has because your cell phone probably has all of them at a better price. I wish they made a combo radar detector/gps because I would upgrade for that.

The final reason I didn't go with the 260w / 255w was I read they do not have the "trip planner" feature. I'm leaving for a business trip tomorrow AM and have put all four destination addresses into my Magellan at once; it will supposedly optimize my travel routes (and it looks good, as checked via paper maps).

I've read the Garmin nuvi 260w can't do that. You have to reach destination 1 and then reprogram from destination 1 to destination 2. Is that true? I've read that the "work around" is to put in destination 1 as a "point of interest" on the way to destination 2, but that's too much work as far as I'm concerned...
 

Bipolarcy

Well-Known Member
Oct 27, 2008
3,216
2,086
113
After years of using fold-up maps in general and print-out google maps for specific addresses, I finally broke down and purchased a GPS unit, primarily for business travel. I did my research and decided on a Magellan model, namely the RoadMate 1430, which I purchased at BestBuy for $199.

I've noticed two things in the short time I've had it. First, it sometimes picks the route that's neither "most direct" nor "fastest". Second, if you miss a turn, my Magellan instructs you to make the "first available legal u-turn" rather than immediately recalculate a new route. It eventually recalculates the new route, but doesn't give any verbal indication that it's done so! I understand the Garmin's announce "recalculating" or something of the sort.

Anybody have any GPS tips, preferences or words of advice?

I have a Magellan too. Mine is a Maestro, which cost about $30 more than yours. The very first time I used it, it was on a trip I've made dozens of times before and it took me a long way away from where I wanted to go. It took me on an Interstate headed west when I wanted to go north. This interstate would eventually take me to a northbound Interstate, but not before I went about 130 miles out of my way on a trip that is normally about 350 miles.

I kept thinking it was going to tell me to exit the interstate and take me the way I am accustomed to going, but it bypassed the first exit that would have done that. On a whim, I decided to follow it, but it bypassed the next exit too. At that point, I decided not to follow it and took the exit. By that time, I had already gone about 10 miles in the wrong direction.

I kept going the way I knew how and at every exit, it told me to take it and head back the opposite way. Once I finally got to a northbound road (about 20 miles after I started ignoring the Magellan) it finally caught up to me and started giving me the correct instructions.

So after that inauspicious start, I was having doubts about this GPS thing. However, I grew to love this Magellan on a vacation trip. It was a looooong road trip in excess of 3,000 miles. The best thing about the Magellan was the stress-free driving on interstates through big cities.

In the past, I was always sitting on the edge of my seat, paying attention to every road sign, stressing if I didn't get to read one. Not with this thing. I knew exactly where my exit was going to be, knew exactly what side of the road to be on and didn't have to watch every sign carefully.

I breezed through Kansas City, something that usually stresses me out to no end, with no problems. It told me in miles how far my exit was, so I didn't even have to LOOK at a road sign until I got within a mile or two of my exit. And I always knew what lane to be in.

The thing I found out about the Magellan, is that it sometimes gets lost when you first start out. That happened to me about three times on this long road trip.

Once it led me to a dead-end in a little Iowa town then couldn't find it's way out of that town (it kept taking me north when I needed to go south), once it told me to take exits where no exits existed in a heavily congested urban area (I just kept going straight because I had no other option and it eventually straightened out) and another time, it told me to exit onto an access road that dead-ended in the parking lot of a motel. This last time, was not during the first part of the trip, but was in the middle of a leg of the trip, which I found to be a tad disconcerting.

I found it works best if you have the exact address of your final destination. You can't just tell it to "take me to Ames," for example. If you make up some address, using the Magellan prompts, you're liable to wind up lost in that town.

Luckily, I had thought to write down that information for the hotels we were staying at and it took me right to the door of our hotel in an urban area that was more congested with more traffic than any urban area I've ever visited in the past.

Also, if you don't have the exact address, sometimes Magellan has it for you. You can look under hotels, for example and it will have a list of hotels near your destination, where you might be able to find yours.

If you just use your Magellan with the idea that it's going to sometimes misdirect you when you first start out in the morning, you should be all right. When that happened, I just stopped and reprogrammed it or just drove through it if I knew the right way to go initially and it eventually started going the right way. Once you're on the road, though and headed in the right direction, it seems to do a good job.

The one thing I wish it had was a map of the area you are in that you could access with a push of a button, so you could track your progress. The map it shows on the screen while you are driving is limited to about 1 or 2 miles.

For instance, if I was driving on Interstate 80 through Illinois at night, it would be nice if I could see how close I come to Chicago and where it might be in relation to where I am.
 
Last edited:

OWLCITYCYFAN

Well-Known Member
Sep 6, 2006
2,637
1,977
113
Iowa City
I have a Magellan too. Mine is a Maestro, which cost about $30 more than yours. The very first time I used it, it was on a trip I've made dozens of times before and it took me a long way away from where I wanted to go.

I grew to love this Magellan on a vacation trip. It was a looooong road trip in excess of 3,000 miles. The best thing about the Magellan was the stress-free driving on interstates through big cities.

Good information for which I thank you! My business trip this week is to an area I know relatively well, so it'll give me a chance to test things! I'm hopeful it'll work well, but I'm not throwing away the fold-up maps just yet!

We're taking the kids to Arizona for Spring Break; while I'm still hoping to fly, if we can't find reasonable airfare the Magellan should prove invaluable. Rather than casting about aimlessly searching for gas stations or restaurants in unfamiliar areas, I can search the POI database for such on upcoming exits.

After driving around town with it for several days and ignoring commands frequently, it's stopped giving me the "make first legal u-turn" verbal prompt and gone straight to recalculating a new route. I've read that Garmin's "learn" your driving habits and adjust ETA's, etc. I wonder if the RoadMate has similar programmed "logic"?

After two days, I'm calling this device "VERY COOL". I should have a clearer picture after my upcoming five-day business trip!