Snowflake ref
- Thread starter amishclone
- Start date
Are you sure he left the line early. The video I watched, his right foot was still clearly on the line when the player strikes the ball.
So nobody is going to give the details of what the crowd said or did? Because without those it seems like the ref was being overly sensitive.
I was a ref for 15 years, you learn fairly quickly that spectators are the bottom rung of sports and should be fully ignored.
One side effect is that I can't watch a game with someone who whines about every call, it's physically impossible for me. I'd rather listen to finger nails on a chalkboard for hours on end.
One side effect is that I can't watch a game with someone who whines about every call, it's physically impossible for me. I'd rather listen to finger nails on a chalkboard for hours on end.
I only watched the video once and at first glance I thought he did, but I could be wrong.
Assuming he did... I’d only make the call if he saved a shoot that was not in the middle of the goal. In case other people don’t know this, leaving the line early is a penalty because it makes easier to defend shots towards the sides, since the goalie minimizes the distance between the goal and ball. It makes no difference in a shot in the middle of the goal; the right thing to do is to warn the goalie saying “hey, watch your foot, if you save a shot towards the corners I’ll have to call it back” ... there no drama.
A penalty is a penalty because it gives somebody an unfair advantage. In this scenario there was no unfair advantage. I elaborated a little more above. In soccer there are offsides all the time that are not called, because the player in the offside position had no impact on the play; therefore no unfair advantage.
Thanks for the clarification. Perhaps they should officiate others sports similarly. How many football games have you watched where gains are nullified due to penalties that occur away from the plays?
Not to mention if a goalie is off his line early it might throw off the kicker, maybe he sees him leave early and last minute changes his mind and goes to the middle knowing the corners just got smaller.
I know most soccer rules, but was the goalie carded for stepping off the line or for behavior after it was called? I've never heard of getting a yellow for that, and I can't find it specifically anywhere online. Or was he warned and kept doing it?
Maybe I am not being clear enough... yes the rule needs to be called when it impacts the outcome of the pk. In this case I don’t even think the goalie left the line and if he did it was so minor that no advantage was really gained. This rule is in place to keep goalies from taking big lounges forward like almost every pk in the video below starting around 4:19.
Last edited:
Sounds like it; pretty sure that’s a fairly new rule.
https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.th...pers-leaving-line-penalties-pierluigi-collina
Care to elaborate? Not saying I’m right or wrong, but I also played soccer for +15 years of my life, so if nothing else I am at least educated on the matter.
