#1: August 22, 1968, Yankees versus the Twins at the old Met. Mantle homered late off of Jim Merritt who pitched a 2-hitter. Mantles last plate appearance in Minnesota. I was a HUGE Mickey fan so it was BIG deal for me. Even had a Cub Scout scrapbook of newspaper clipping from back in the day.
#2: Game 6 and game 7 of the 1991 World Series in the Metrodome. Puckett walk off and then walk off in the 10th again to win it all with Morris going 10. **** yeah!
#3: Some game in the late 1970's at the old Met against the Yankees. Reggie Jackson hit a foul ball behind the third base box seats where we were. Cheap ass stadium, the seats were folding metal chairs. Chairs went tumbling over as this scrum of dudes fought for the ball. Out of the bottom of the scrum rolled the ball. My girlfriend just reached down and picked it up much to the chagrin of the scrum. She was a Yankee fan so that was cool. Still remember the look she gave them and the look she got back from them. Priceless.
Honorable mention: 1985 All-Star game with Nolan Ryan knocking down Dave Winfield. Woof! And that AL lineup (even though they lost) seven Hall of Famers.
1. Rickey Henderson, OF, New York Yankees
2. Lou Whitaker, 2B, Detroit Tigers
3. George Brett, 3B, Kansas City Royals
4. Eddie Murray, 1B, Baltimore Orioles
5. Cal Ripken, Jr., SS, Baltimore Orioles
6. Dave Winfield, OF, New York Yankees
7. Jim Rice, OF, Boston Red Sox
8. Carlton Fisk, C, Chicago White Sox
9. Jack Morris, P, Detroit Tigers