Tirrell Rennie over Steele Jantz?

[Clones21]

Andy Garmin on "Out of Bounds" just said he thinks Rennie could play for ISU. I take that as he thinks Rennie would start over Steele. That sounds a little over the top. I don't think Rennie is a Big 12 QB or even has the arm talent to be one. Don't get me wrong, Rennie is FAST. I just don't think he has the arm to even compete with Steele.

 

[cyhiphopp]

Dude, with your track record I don't think it's wise to start threads with titles like this. A lot of posters will immediately assume that you've given up on Jantz.

 

[3TrueFans]

Dude, with your track record I don't think it's wise to start threads

 

[Clones21]

Dude, with your track record I don't think it's wise to start threads with titles like this. A lot of posters will immediately assume that you've given up on Jantz.

Well to get that out of the way. I have a man crush on Jantz. They know that.

 

[chuckd4735]

I'm still surprised Garmin is allowed to talk.

 

[CyBer]

He knows the right direction, no matter where you are in the world.

 

[CloneFan4]

Andy Garmin on "Out of Bounds" just said he thinks Rennie could play for ISU. I take that as he thinks Rennie would start over Steele. That sounds a little over the top. I don't think Rennie is a Big 12 QB or even has the arm talent to be one. Don't get me wrong, Rennie is FAST. I just don't think he has the arm to even compete with Steele.

Anybody else get a good laugh out of this?

 

[dualthreat]

Coming out of ellsworth two years ago, we had every opportunity to get this guy and passed on him. Whether it be good or bad. I bet he was better than JT last year.

 

[Naughtius]

Which one looks better in yoga pants?

 

[CloneFan4]

Which one looks better in yoga pants?

LMAO!! Whichever does look better they must have STDs up the ying yang.

 

[Clones21]

Coming out of ellsworth two years ago, we had every opportunity to get this guy and passed on him. Whether it be good or bad. I bet he was better than JT last year.

I would most definitely want to have Rennie over Tiller. Tiller never could make people miss with his feet. He was only fast out in the open.

 

[cyhiphopp]

To the original question...
I think Rennie is talented enough to play at ISU, but I don't think he'd start at QB. He'd probably make an excellent slot reciever or DB (if strong enough).

I also don't assume that Garmin is asserting that Rennie would start over Steele, just that he has enough talent to play at ISU. He'd make a decent backup QB and could deffinitely run the read option. Steele has shown enough talent that it might be safe to assume that even the stupidest of local media wouldn't seriously think that Rennie would start over Steele at ISU. It might also just be Garmin trying to make a sensational claim to try and get people to pay attention.

 

[DRCHIRO]

Andy Garmin on "Out of Bounds" just said he thinks Rennie could play for ISU. I take that as he thinks Rennie would start over Steele. That sounds a little over the top. I don't think Rennie is a Big 12 QB or even has the arm talent to be one. Don't get me wrong, Rennie is FAST. I just don't think he has the arm to even compete with Steele.

Does Garmin think Rennie could play for Iowa?

 

[Omaha Cy]

Rennie is completing about 56% of his passes this year at the FCS level. 5 TD/No INTs.
800+ yards. He's primarily a runner. Nearly 500 yards rushing on the season.

 

[Tedcyclone]

Not a chance.. Steele is my guy, our guy, ISUs guy.. hes a stud, and i wouldnt trade him for anyone...

I love this team... they give 100% every play and have talent. im looking for all out effort on every down. love this team.

ps steele is way better than Rennie.. not even close.

 

[CyBer]

Does Garmin think Rennie could play for Iowa?

No, but if Iowa was recruiting him he would surely be recruited by another Big 10 team.

 

[UNIGuy4Cy]

Can he kick? He could make kicker

 

[Clones21]

Does Garmin think Rennie could play for Iowa?

Nope. Doesn't think he would fit their system.

 

[Frak]

I think that he'd make a good slot WR and Wildcat QB. Starting QB? No way. We'd see 9 man fronts every game.

 

[cyhawk55]

To add a twist to this thread it seems like the concensus is that Rennie wouldn't make it at Iowa State but what if we hired their offensive coordinator? UNI's offense is so diverse in what they do it is very difficult for other teams to stop because they do so many things.