Andy Katz

[cyclonenum1]

What does this pillar of journalistic excellence have to say about ISU and GM at this point?

At the beginning of the season he was showering us with “loveâ€￾ as a team that could surprise.

What is he regurgitating now?

 

[Stewo]

Yeah. What a jerk for being the olny one in the country to give us love.

 

[bos]

Fire Katz.

 

[bos]

Wait, shove his face in his positive words and then fire him.

 

[kgreeny]

Don't take it out on him that we suck.

If anybody nat'l wants to talk nice about us, we should take it and run. Now we just need to do something. What is it, again?....Oh, WIN A GAME.

It's not Andys fault.

 

[brokenloginagain]

Andy made a "call" that we might be a surprise team in 2010. Big deal.

Our old pal Gregg Doyel made a call that we'd be a surprise team in 2006 - that didn't work out for us either

 

[tman24]

What does this pillar of journalistic excellence have to say about ISU and GM at this point?

At the beginning of the season he was showering us with “loveâ€￾ as a team that could surprise.

What is he regurgitating now?

Well this was a surprise wasnt it. So it looks like he was right.

 

[Cloned4Life]

What does this pillar of journalistic excellence have to say about ISU and GM at this point?

At the beginning of the season he was showering us with “loveâ€￾ as a team that could surprise.

What is he regurgitating now?

Huh? What is the point of this post?

Katz said we had a chance to be the surprise team of the Big 12. My hopeful side thought we did too. Hell, logically I thought this team had a great chance to be a player in this conference.

He was wrong. I was wrong.

I like Katz....not sure why you posted what you posted...makes it seem like you don't like Katz for some reason and that he predicted Iowa State would be awesome and is now an idiot because we suck...

 

[Wesley]

Unless we make offensive and defensive changes, we will not be a surprise or prize team in 2011.

 

[BigBake]

On paper he was right. At the beginning of season we had the makings of what should have been a good year.

 

[ISUFan22]

Huh? What is the point of this post?

Katz said we had a chance to be the surprise team of the Big 12. My hopeful side thought we did too. Hell, logically I thought this team had a great chance to be a player in this conference.

He was wrong. I was wrong.

I like Katz....not sure why you posted what you posted...makes it seem like you don't like Katz for some reason and that he predicted Iowa State would be awesome and is now an idiot because we suck...

I'd like to know as well. But it is pretty much par for the course in this case.

 

[dtclones]

Huh? What is the point of this post?

Katz said we had a chance to be the surprise team of the Big 12. My hopeful side thought we did too. Hell, logically I thought this team had a great chance to be a player in this conference.

He was wrong. I was wrong.

I like Katz....not sure why you posted what you posted...makes it seem like you don't like Katz for some reason and that he predicted Iowa State would be awesome and is now an idiot because we suck...

Yeah, between Katz and Gottlieb, we get a lot more love than we deserve. Or at least a lot more love than anyone else at ESPN gives us. They've always been on our side and usually put ISU in a good light.

 

[cyclonenum1]

Huh? What is the point of this post?

Katz said we had a chance to be the surprise team of the Big 12. My hopeful side thought we did too. Hell, logically I thought this team had a great chance to be a player in this conference.

He was wrong. I was wrong.

I like Katz....not sure why you posted what you posted...makes it seem like you don't like Katz for some reason and that he predicted Iowa State would be awesome and is now an idiot because we suck...

Simple...the purpose is I want to know what Katz is "reporting" about us now. I think I was pretty clear about that.

No, I am not a big fan of his and I don't hang on his every word...hence I am not going to seek out myself what he is currently saying. I am just curious. Whether he says nice stuff or not about ISU, Katz is a tool that does nothing more than regurgitate what the people he talks to want communicated over the ESPN airwaves...he is a dupe.

Gottlieb, on the other hand, I have a lot of respect for. He is very insightful.

 

[brokenloginagain]

Simple...the purpose is I want to know what Katz is "reporting" about us now. I think I was pretty clear about that.

No, I am not a big fan of his and I don't hang on his every word...hence I am not going to seek out myself what he is currently saying. I am just curious. Whether he says nice stuff or not about ISU, Katz is a tool that does nothing more than regurgitate what the people he talks to want communicated over the ESPN airwaves...he is a dupe.

Gottlieb, on the other hand, I have a lot of respect for. He is very insightful.

uh, aren't reporters supposed to....uh...report? you know, talk to people and quote them?

Gottlieb hosts a radio show and write columns. He's supposed to provide opinions.

 

[ISUChippewa]

No, I am not a big fan of his and I don't hang on his every word...hence I am not going to seek out myself what he is currently saying. I am just curious. Whether he says nice stuff or not about ISU, Katz is a tool that does nothing more than regurgitate what the people he talks to want communicated over the ESPN airwaves...he is a dupe.

Wow, what did the guy do? Beat you up in junior high for your lunch money? Steal your girlfriend?

 

[Tre4ISU]

Simple...the purpose is I want to know what Katz is "reporting" about us now. I think I was pretty clear about that.

No, I am not a big fan of his and I don't hang on his every word...hence I am not going to seek out myself what he is currently saying. I am just curious. Whether he says nice stuff or not about ISU, Katz is a tool that does nothing more than regurgitate what the people he talks to want communicated over the ESPN airwaves...he is a dupe.

Gottlieb, on the other hand, I have a lot of respect for. He is very insightful.

Aren't you doing this by asking us to do your leg work? It's the same thing. Just because you aren't reading his stuff directly doesn't mean you aren't seeking out what he is saying.

 

[cyclonenum1]

uh, aren't reporters supposed to....uh...report? you know, talk to people and quote them?

Gottlieb hosts a radio show and write columns. He's supposed to provide opinions.

Unfortunately, in today's world that is what passes as journalism...nothing more than regurgitating someone's talking points.