Discussion in 'Mens Basketball' started by cyclonenum1, Nov 15, 2009.

  1. cyclonenum1

    cyclonenum1 Well-Known Member

    Nov 30, 2006
    Obviously, there have been disappointments for us as Cyclone fans over the years...both on and off the field/court.

    However, the reactions of some Cyclone faithful over the past couple of years on this site have really been eye opening and disappointing to me.

    The way many of you treat these 15-22 year old kids that are either being recruited by ISU or are playing for ISU is nearly unbelievable. While they are either considering playing for ISU or playing for ISU they are pumped up beyond reality...they are smart, classy, ultra-talented. As soon as they either choose elsewhere or leave ISU they are castigated by many on this site as total losers. This has happened a lot...Bates, Wesley Johnson, Staten, HB just to name the primary examples. One day they are classy...the next they are a total slimeball loser.

    Then there is the constant ridicule we get of any coach/program that beats us on or off the court/field. They are immediately accused of being slimy, cheating, and not doing things the right way...all with no evidence whatsoever with respect to any of the allegations.

    I understand frustration and anger...and believe me, I get frustrated and angry...but to place this on 15-22 year old kids or on our opponents is misguided in my opinion. I would really like to see this fanbase start holding the adults more accountable for the results in our programs. Ultimately, these coaches are in total control of the program they run and getting paid quite handsomely by ISU to run it.

    I think we need to start looking in the mirror rather than out the window when trying to understand why a particular Cyclone program is struggling.
    • Like Like x 3
  2. CyCloned

    CyCloned Well-Known Member

    Oct 18, 2006
    Robins, Iowa
    This is, of course, about, HB, and I think most ISU fans understand that he had a lot of choices, good choices, and he took UNC over ISU even though his connections to ISU were much stronger. It all comes down to you win some and you loose some. Because HB lived in Ames and was so close to the current player and coaching staff this one hurt pretty bad, but in the end , it is his life and his decision. ISU MBB will move on.
  3. woodie

    woodie Well-Known Member

    Apr 10, 2006
    what programs are struggling???? seems like cpr is righting the ship for football. wrestling seems to be in good hands. coach mac seems to be putting together a very good basketball team.
    basketball was left in bad shape by wayne morgan. gmac has had some struggles in the men's basketball due to the loss of some primadonnas.when the primadonnas have left ,the boys that want to play basketball are shoring up the ship and are loooking pretty good in the games which we have played. our ladies basketball and ladies volleyball plus gymnastics seem to be doing very well.

    as the old lady that used to advertise for wendys used to say""""""where's the beef????""""
  4. Tre4ISU

    Tre4ISU Well-Known Member

    Dec 30, 2008
    Bates and Wesley Johnson quit on us. That's not the same as HB. I think that had HB removed us from the running weeks ago, when he knew he wasn't coming here, there would be a lot less negative feelings. Instead he dragged us a long and invited the Ames public to his signing to let us down like that. I think that's what the negative feelings are about.
  5. CyAg

    CyAg Well-Known Member

    May 22, 2006
    Fans of every team tend to claim the aer the classy fans and the other team fans are not. It is human nature down to a basic level. So evertying needs to be taken with a grain of salt.

    And if this is about HB, in my opinion, no one should be criticising him on where he decided to go. He has to make that decision for himself.

    However, how he did it, announced, and the ramifications and effects are fair game. He orchestrated this from a public relations and marketing perspective. I posted early last week from a PR perspective this would create the potential for risk and it did.

    There seems to be be almost a professional branding campaign underway and frankly, they are not doing very well for how it impacts the image.
  6. Gizmo

    Gizmo Member

    Mar 11, 2006
    I think an argument can be made that HB made the safe choice in picking NC. He will be one of many highly recruited players on a team with a history of final fours and national titles. If they don't win a title or make the final four it is not all on him. Like many of you, I wanted him at ISU. I respect his choice but I really disliked the big show he put on in Ames on Friday.
  7. joefrog

    joefrog Well-Known Member

    Apr 29, 2008
    Clive, Iowa
    This right here. I, like many, was not all that upset with hb's choice. The problem is with the manner in which he made it. If one is honest and looks back at the whole hb thing, it is easy to see how he really used the whole ISU community, and I mean bad. He had every right to go wherever he wanted, for sure. I just think he should have cut ISU loose earlier, instead of playing up ISU's chances in order to get more attendance at the production in the gym for ESPN.

    That being said, hb is gone. No problems here. I want team players, and Cyclones on the field and on the court. I am not going to be told that I have to wish him well or cheer for him however. I am a Cyclone fan. Let his Ames groupies take care of continuing to puff up his ego. Don't worry, they will show up here in a hurry.

    Me? I cannot wait to see Melvin Ejim hit the court.
  8. CycloneErik

    CycloneErik Well-Known Member

    Jan 31, 2008
    Grad Student
    Melvin Ejim is going to be something! :smile:
  9. CloneBack

    CloneBack Member

    Apr 17, 2007
    West Des Moines
    - this
  10. cyclonestate

    cyclonestate Well-Known Member

    May 4, 2009
    Like many folks, I don't fault HB's choice, I just fault the way he manipulated the whole Ames/ISU community for his own benefit. I'm sure it made for great TV and it made the family feel great, but it the Cyclone faithful feel like they were used. But I've already moved on. I have absolutely no interest in HB anymore.

    I know I'm stretching for a silver lining in this, but at least we won't have to deal with all the distractions that his presence on the team would have undoubtedly brought. Next year, we will have a roster of guys who are all on the same level, not a roster with one superstar and the rest members of the supporting cast. Next year, it will all be about the TEAM'S success.
    • Like Like x 1
  11. twistedredbird

    twistedredbird Well-Known Member

    Apr 26, 2008
    Executive Director
    I think it is only natural for those of us who are disappointed, to vent our frustrations to others who understand our pain. Its called coping.

    And there is nothing wrong with these youth realizing that their decisions do impact other people. They shouldn't make their decisions for other people, but they should learn to be respectful of others. HB's show this week, was not. It was painful. It was going to be painful no matter what, but the ostentation display was like rubbing salt into a wound. Perhaps he might learn from this experience not to play with people's emotions like that. I don't think it was intentional, but it came across as selfish marketing that even top media people have said has set a new "over the top" standard for how to announce commitments. WJ may have had legitimate concerns to go elsewhere, but how he handled it was not in a very upstanding manner. All stars must deal learn how to handle themselves cautiously. Its not fair, but in the end fan appeal makes them money, if they are not liked, they make less money. If we didn't buy tickets and watch sports on TV, this would not occur, but we are all fanatics in the end.
  12. CyinCo

    CyinCo Well-Known Member

    Mar 24, 2006
    Clive, IA
    The past is the past. Move on.
  13. cycoticfan

    cycoticfan Member

    Dec 14, 2008
    Johnston IA
    Don't forget all the petty little boys who left when Morgan got booted (Taggart, especially) Rashon was the real only man from that team. At least the football players got it right by sticking around.

    All you negative little whiners should be glad you have a team on the rise instead of one like EIU headed for mediocity. A lot of you weren't around when we had Nance coaching. Talk about laughin stock.....
  14. CTAClone

    CTAClone Addict

    Mar 28, 2006
    First Assistant Director
    For all the years I've been coming to the site...the way some of the cyclone faithful carry hate on their sleeves is really eye opening to me. It seems no matter what happens they are always unhappy and always try to take out their hate on coaches/ads. No matter what happens or what the state of the program is they always seem to be very vocal on their feelings of a coach or AD.

    It gets really really old always hearing the same old thing from them. We get it, you don't like the coach. I don't think there is one single coach that we have ever had that could have gotten HB to come play for us next season. If we were continually in the post season and considered a top-tier program I think we may have had a shot. I look in the mirror and I see a program that is finally having some stability and the future looks very bright. When I look in the mirror I'm very happy with where the program is right now and have no reason to get upset or angry. I finally feel that we are establishing ourselves as a program to be trifled with for years to come.
    • Like Like x 1
  15. SeattleClone

    SeattleClone Well-Known Member

    Aug 15, 2006
    1. Thank you for telling ME how to feel about it. I was very confused and didn't know what to do or what to think. You have shown me the way.

    2. Thank you for starting your own thread, because obviously your take on the situation is very unique and wise, and it is important that everyone sees it. If your opinion had gotten lost in one of the other hundreds of threads since the decision had been made, it would have been a great tragedy.

    3. :jimlad:
    • Like Like x 2
  16. Cyismybird

    Cyismybird Member

    Oct 17, 2009
    Exactly. HB must realize this wasn't just about him. There is a school that is paying him to play for them (in the form of a scholarship which is like a salary), therefore the fans do have a stake in this. His actions were selfish on Friday, no matter how good of a kid he is. To invite Cyclone nation to his UNC announcement was bush league. His decision should have been made before he made arrangements for the announcement. Then he could have maybe made better choices on how to do it.
  17. CYNWIA

    CYNWIA Member

    Nov 13, 2008
    people have been posting negative comments about far worse for years on the internet... my guess is half of the people you are talking about arent nearly as negative in person, and when they are at the games... its the nature of the internet. When shielded with anonymity people will say some pretty drastic things, when they probably wouldn't say those things normally... if you dont like it, get off the internet
  18. erikbj

    erikbj Well-Known Member

    Aug 31, 2006
    compliance officer
    hiawatha, ia
    His mom is to blame as much or more. You can say, well he's 18 and didn't know better. His mom was the one sending out invites to everyone in town. She knew he wasn't going to ISU (her employer) and to let this event take place.

    He should have done a private ceremony like 99.999% of all other kids do and I am guessing everyone would have been fine, disappointed but fine with it.

    Life is full of lessons and I am guessing he learned a valuable one on friday, because I am guessing the love he had from the Ames community has deminished and he burned some friendships that he will regret.
  19. BigBake

    BigBake Well-Known Member

    Mar 17, 2006
    Programming monkey
    1. His method/circus method of delivering his choice was very poor.

    2. I will never root for UNC and likewise never root for him or wish him good luck. Why any Cyclone fan would ever root for UNC is beyond me. (even before he committed)
  20. BigBake

    BigBake Well-Known Member

    Mar 17, 2006
    Programming monkey
    4. I'll repost my opinion each and every time someone tries to tell me I should feel different.

Share This Page