MLB: Cubs Cut Roster from 58 to 40
- Thread starter cigaretteman
- Start date
How could the ever think about cutting clevenger and McNutt...
There goes the world series with the loss of those two.
Nothing earth shattering here. I think the biggest decisions to be made is who gets the utility infielder spot, the #5 spot in the rotation (pretty sure Wells has locked up #4 by now) and the makeup of the bullpen.
I think you can pretty much say these guys are a lock:
1B Pena
2B Baker and DeWitt
3B A-Ram
SS Castro
OF Soriano, Byrd, Colvin, Fukudome
C Soto and Hill
Rotation: Dempster, Garza, Zambrano, Wells
Bullpen: Marmol, Wood, Grabow, Marshall, Samardzija (because he is out of options)
Pitchers that will likely have some kind of role: Silva, Cashner, Russell
That makes 11 position players and 12 pitchers for sure, Russell potentially could be sent down or Silva traded meaning 22 or 23 of the 25 spots are probably filled. Barney, Scales, and Ojeda are battling for the utility infielder spot and probably in that order are the most likely to get it and I'm guessing a 5th OF like Reed Johnson or Fernando Perez is going to get that last spot. For the bullpen or rotation Braden Looper, Todd Wellemeyer, and Casey Coleman are still all in the mix as well. Guys like Matt Camp and Scott Moore have impressed in ST so far but are longshots to make the roster.
I think you can pretty much say these guys are a lock:
1B Pena
2B Baker and DeWitt
3B A-Ram
SS Castro
OF Soriano, Byrd, Colvin, Fukudome
C Soto and Hill
Rotation: Dempster, Garza, Zambrano, Wells
Bullpen: Marmol, Wood, Grabow, Marshall, Samardzija (because he is out of options)
Pitchers that will likely have some kind of role: Silva, Cashner, Russell
That makes 11 position players and 12 pitchers for sure, Russell potentially could be sent down or Silva traded meaning 22 or 23 of the 25 spots are probably filled. Barney, Scales, and Ojeda are battling for the utility infielder spot and probably in that order are the most likely to get it and I'm guessing a 5th OF like Reed Johnson or Fernando Perez is going to get that last spot. For the bullpen or rotation Braden Looper, Todd Wellemeyer, and Casey Coleman are still all in the mix as well. Guys like Matt Camp and Scott Moore have impressed in ST so far but are longshots to make the roster.
From what I've read, it sounds like they really want Cashner as the fifth starter. Samardzija's out of options too, but I guess he could stay in the bullpen.
Last edited:
Samardzija will be in the bullpen, is not being looked at as a starter. That's already been decided.
Samardzija has been a disappointment. He's really struggled with his command the past couple seasons and this is sort of a make or break year for him probably. The Cubs can't run him through waivers because he'd easily be claimed so they have to hope he can figure it out this season with the big club. I think Cashner is the favorite to get the 5th spot in the rotation probably
I expect Samardzija to be dealt in July when the cubs are trying to upgrade at 2B or OF.
I think he will do well in the bull pen this year though. Nice power arm that can come in and get a K.
I think he will do well in the bull pen this year though. Nice power arm that can come in and get a K.
Samardzjia get hits harder than any pitcher I can remember. I don't mean that he's giving up the most runs or that he's the worst pitcher I've ever seen, but the balls guys hit off him are just rockets. It's not a good sign when you're consistently giving up hard hit line drives.
CycloneErik
Well-Known Member
This article makes me think that this really is our year!
MLB Opening Day 2011 to fall on Friday, April 1; season to end on a Wednesday - Daily Pitch: MLB News, Standings, Schedules & More - USATODAY.com
What could be more perfect. Joke's on you, everybody else!
MLB Opening Day 2011 to fall on Friday, April 1; season to end on a Wednesday - Daily Pitch: MLB News, Standings, Schedules & More - USATODAY.com
What could be more perfect. Joke's on you, everybody else!
All Samardzjia has is a fastball. His secondary pitches aren't good, and that's putting it lightly. You can get away with overpowering hitters in college but not in the majors. Everyone can hit a fastball.
